the film
Commentaries and editorials

An 'Extinction Event' Is Unfolding in Washington State
as Two More Endangered Orcas Fall Ill

by Yessenia Funes
Gizmodo, January 4, 2019

"We're going to be working with federal agencies to really advocate for the removal
of those (Lower Snake) dams as a necessary step to save orcas," Krehbiel told Earther.

J-17 on the last day of 2018. Remember that orca mom that carried around her dead calf for more than two weeks in the Pacific Northwest's Salish Sea? Tahlequah, also known as J-35, had a rough year, and 2019 isn't shaping out to be much better for her. Now, her 42-year-old mother, J-17, appears malnourished and isn't expected to make it through the summer, reports the Seattle Times.

J-17 isn't the only southern resident orca whose health is quickly deteriorating either; so is K-25, a 25-year-old male from another pod. The entire southern resident killer whale population, which is made up of three pods, is threatened by extinction. The endangered species has only 74 members left since the loss of a young female last year. At this point, every death hurts species recovery, said Misty MacDuffee, the wild salmon program director for Raincoast Conservation Foundation.

"With every loss, we lose reproductive capacity," she told Earther.

After all, this population hasn't seen a successful pregnancy in three years. While scientists had documented pregnancies in some whales last year, they haven't seen any newborns. The species must grow if it's going to survive.

Growth, however, requires food. Starvation and malnutrition are what's killing J-17 and K-25. Unfortunately, these whales are a picky bunch and almost exclusively eat chinook salmon, one of the larger salmon species that's also endangered and threatened. The only way to save the orca is to recover their food source. And that's easier said than done.

MacDuffee and her organization are focused on commercial and recreational fishing in Pacific waters, which they say is key to saving the salmon and, in turn, the orca. However, while the state is aware overfishing is a concern, the Southern Resident Orca Task Force organized by Governor Jay Inslee last year has identified three other factors as primary drivers of the orca decline: A lack of salmon driven by development and habitat loss, noise from vessel traffic, and toxic contaminants.

Noise makes it more difficult for the whales to find food. The toxins, meanwhile, are setting up baby whales, who depend on their mother's toxic milk, to fail. A study last year showed that polychlorinated biphenyls, or PCBs, have infiltrated the bodies of these marine mammals despite bans in the 1970s and 1980s. They're still in our environment, especially our waterways. All this is harming our orcas.

"We are witnessing an extinction event," said Robb Krehbiel, a working group member of the task force and is the northwest representative for Defenders of Wildlife, to Earther.

Solving all these issues will take time and money. Governor Inslee has requested more than $1 billion in investments toward orca recovery, including boosting the enforcement of environmental laws that already exist, increasing salmon hatchery production, and consulting stakeholders over the removal of dams that impact salmon migration. Salmon in the Columbia and Snake river systems must traverse some 14 dams to migrate; these hydropower developments are harming them and ultimately the orcas.

"We think [the dams] should go, and we're going to be working with federal agencies to really advocate for the removal of those dams as a necessary step to save orcas," Krehbiel told Earther.

Inslee has not come out in full support of removing the dams, but he is open to discussing it.

However, none of this can do much for the two orcas who are suffering now. Officials with the National Oceanic Atmospheric Administration tried to save J-50, the young orca that died last year, by feeding her medicated fish, and she still died.

"The fact is we can't save these whales on a case-by-case basis," Krehbiel said. "What we really need to do is invest in the long-term recovery of the population by recovering the salmon they rely on."

One endangered species relies on another endangered species—and it's all our fault. People are the only ones who can save the southern resident killer whale population.

Related Pages:
Orcas Need More than Sympathy and Prayers by John Rosenberg, High Country News, 8/15/18
Save the Orcas? We'll Have To Do This One, Radical Thing by Daniel Jack Chasan, Crosscut, 8/17/18
The Immoral Reaction to an Orca Mother's Grief by Todd Myers, Tri-City Herald, 8/17/18
The Orca Task Force Not to the Rescue by Pat Neal, Peninsula Daily News, 8/15/18
'Climate Change' is a Hoax by Tom Nelson, The Columbian, 8/12/18
Blaming Snake River Dams for Orca Woes a Hoax by John McKern, Walla Walla Union-Bulletin, 8/14/18
We Must Band Together to Protect Our Most Important Regional Asset -- the Snake River Dams by Utility Managers, Tri-City Herald, 8/11/18
Giving up Chinook Is a Nice Idea But It Will Not Save the Orcas by Katie Herzog, The Stranger, 8/22/18
Seattle Chef's Gesture Aims to Help Hungry Orcas by Lynda Mapes, Seattle Times, 8/22/18
As World Watches, Plight of Southern Resident Orcas Grows More Severe by Amy Carey, Vashon Island Beachcomber, 8/15/18
Saving the Orcas: Meetings, Meetings and More Meetings by Erik Lacitis, Seattle Times, 8/14/18
Orca Extinction is Not an Option by Kevin Ranker, Seattle Times, 8/14/18
Death Watch for Killer Whales? by John Stang, Everett Herald, 8/14/18

Yessenia Funes
An 'Extinction Event' Is Unfolding in Washington State as Two More Endangered Orcas Fall Ill
Gizmodo, January 4, 2019

See what you can learn

learn more on topics covered in the film
see the video
read the script
learn the songs
discussion forum
salmon animation