the film
Commentaries and editorials

Agreement Developed in Secret by White House
Diminishes Power Supply

by Gary Wiens
Flathead Beacon, December 2, 2023

If enacted, the 220,000 Montanans served by
these co-ops could lose access to this power

Graphic: Breaching the Lower Snake River dams will result in the recovery of Idaho's wild Salmon and Steelhead. reported by the Fish Passage Center in their 2017 Comparative System Survival study. A recent agreement negotiated in secret by the White House could have serious consequences for western Montana electric cooperatives.

The federal government is planning by Dec. 15 to sign an agreement with Oregon and Washington, along with four tribes outside of Montana.

The agreement was developed in secret without input from public power customers such as western Montana's electric cooperatives, which depend on the power produced by hydroelectric dams in the Basin to deliver affordable, reliable and carbon-free electricity to their members.

Terms of the agreement were ordered by the government to remain confidential but were made public by several federal lawmakers. The agreement paves the way for breaching of the lower Snake River dams, and lays out a plan to replace consistent baseload hydroelectric power with less reliable, more expensive, intermittent renewable energy.

If enacted, the 220,000 Montanans served by these co-ops could lose access to this power.

Montana's electric cooperatives are most alarmed at the agreement's plans to alter water flows to reduce electricity generation, adversely impacting much more than power generation. Other affected interests include irrigation and municipal water supply, recreation, and even Montana grain shipments.

The agreement would also commit the government to fund and provide technical assistance to non-Montana tribes to develop replacement power, should Congress authorize lower Snake River dam breaching.

Western Montana's cooperatives would likely see significantly escalated costs, higher rates, and limited power availability, creating a greater risk of rolling blackouts in the region.

This agreement is wrong for Montana. The 2023 Montana Legislature overwhelmingly approved a joint resolution on a bipartisan vote expressly opposing breaching the lower Snake River dams, with near-unanimous support from the Montana Indian Caucus. And a 2022 scientific statewide poll of Montana voters showed strong support for hydroelectric dams, including the lower Snake River dams.

I urge all Montanans to contact Sens. Jon Tester and Steve Daines and Reps. Matt Rosendale and Ryan Zinke without delay, asking them to help stop this secretly developed government agreement that hurts western Montana electricity consumers.

Related Pages:
Judge Redden Says Tear Snake River Dams Down by Aaron Kunz, Boise State Public Radio, 4/25/12

Gary Wiens is the CEO of the Montana Electric Cooperatives' Association.
Agreement Developed in Secret by White House Diminishes Power Supply
Flathead Beacon, December 2, 2023

See what you can learn

learn more on topics covered in the film
see the video
read the script
learn the songs
discussion forum
salmon animation