the film


Commentaries and editorials

Salmon Recovery Waits on Obama

by Editorial Board
The Daily Astorian, November 13, 2012

Sen. Wyden's committee chairmanship should get the president's attention

"Divide and conquer" is the oldest political strategy in the world, but it assumes there is a single opponent pulling the strings. When it comes to Pacific Northwest salmon recovery, there is no villainous manipulator. It is a failure to work together that keeps us away from effective long-range answers.

With President Obama about to begin his valedictory term in the White House and a new governor taking office in Washington state, the time is ripe for genuine leadership. This leadership must take the form of bringing all interested parties together in a unified process of finding common ground.

Oregon Sen. Ron Wyden will soon become chairman of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committe. That will give Wyden a platform from which to get President Obama's attention on this pressing matter.

The old ways have worked somewhat, but at enormous expense. Unlike the 1990s, there isn't the sense of immediate dire crisis that resulted in fishing season cancelations and fears of near-term extinction for important upriver salmon runs.

Successes have come from almost the full spectrum of stakeholders. From the Columbia River treaty tribes to local watershed councils, there have been incremental improvements in restoring degraded habitat, streams have been relinked with the Columbia and its larger tributaries, better passage has been provided around dams, hatchery-rearing practices have improved.

Many of these gains are tenuous and fragile. Industrial pressures grow in the Columbia-Snake watershed. Climate and ocean chemistry changes threaten salmon -- and humanity -- in fundamental ways. Demand for seafood grows, putting people in ever more direct competition with salmon.

All our efforts, all the billions of dollars spent, have at best provided a little breathing room.

Time and time again, now-retired federal Judge James Redden found previous federal recovery plans were inadequate. In just 13 months, agencies must provide a fourth "biological opinion," an outline for recovery actions, for judicial review.

Although their jobs would in some ways be simplified if wild salmon would go extinct, even hydropower system managers, irrigators and barge operators are deeply linked to the Northwest and our region's salmon legacy. Now at each other's throats over Oregon Gov. John Kitzhaber's troubled alternative proposal to the now defeated Ballot Measure 81 gillnet ban, even sport and commercial fishermen would be willing to work together if it meant a secure, fair future for salmon. The Columbia River Inter-Tribal Fish Commission stated treaty tribes "remain committed to rebuilding abundance for our treaty rights and the entire public."

What all are waiting for is leadership with sufficient belief in the deliberative, democratic process to bring stakeholders together for tough negotiations. We all want certainty that salmon will be around for our grandchildren.

We don't want dysfunctional division.

We want workable answers, fair and predictable allocations and a lasting framework for real sustainable salmon recovery.

Related Sites:
2011 FCRPS BiOp Report
2012 draft Comparative Survival Study

Editorial Board
Settling Fish vs. Dams: Is There a Better Time?
The Daily Astorian, November 13, 2012

See what you can learn

learn more on topics covered in the film
see the video
read the script
learn the songs
discussion forum
salmon animation