the film
Commentaries and editorials

Upstream Battle

by David Liberty
Seattle Times, February 19, 2008

John Balzar's recent opinion regarding sea lions has some good points but poor logic.

The dams are killing federally-protected chinook salmon, but Balzar makes no suggestion that dams should be removed as part of the solution. Dams also provide a bottleneck for spawning salmon that now have a very narrow path of escape if they want to get upriver. This provides sea lions with a feast like they have never seen. Their impact directly affects the tribes who have fishing rights above Bonneville Dam. Yet Balzar suggests we do nothing.

Each year the sea lions arrive earlier and stay longer. Indeed, killing sea lions won't save federally-protected chinook salmon, but it may help a few more get to their spawning grounds. I say it's worth it.

Related Pages:
Killing Sea Lions Will Not Save Columbia River Salmon by John Balzar, Seattle Times, 2/18/8
Tribes Support Lethal Removal of Predatory Sea Lions by Staff, Indian Country, 2/18/8
Sea Lions vs. Salmon: Restore Balance and Common Sense by Fidelia Andy, Seattle Times, 2/15/8

David Liberty, Hood River, Oregon
Upstream Battle
Seattle Times, February 19, 2008

See what you can learn

learn more on topics covered in the film
see the video
read the script
learn the songs
discussion forum
salmon animation