the film
Commentaries and editorials

Wildlife Experts are Resigned
to Extinction of Some Species

by Rocky Barker
Bellingham Herald, June 30, 2008

Ecosystems will adapt to climate change, scientists say

BOISE, Idaho - The fast-moving realities of climate change are forcing wildlife advocates and environmentalists to rethink longheld beliefs, including whether all endangered species should be saved.

Take Defenders of Wildlife climate scientist Jean Brennan, who suggests that it may be time to change the Endangered Species Act to allow some species to go extinct. That belief underscores the crisis she and others say the West and the world faces from climate change.

The nation's top scientists say climate warming is "unequivocal," and much of it is "very likely due" to human causes - and that has forced corporations, investors and government officials to ponder old questions in new ways.

Do the benefits of nuclear energy outweigh the risks? Will drawnout court battles on governmental decisions cause more environmental harm than they do good?

"If you think too much about it, it sends you into despair," said Pat Parenteau, an environmental law professor at the University of Vermont.

But federal and state scientists and managers say they have no choice but to start, and they gathered in Boise last week at the first gathering of federal officials to look ahead at what policies and strategies need to be changed.

Twenty to 40 percent of all known species could go extinct, said Jeff Burgett, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service biologist and endangered species recovery expert.

Scientists say that even if greenhouse gases are dramatically reduced, it will take more than 100 years to dissipate the high levels of carbon dioxide already in the atmosphere.

The dire news was a wake-up call for agency biologists, regional managers and others who were hardly allowed even to discuss climate change during the last eight years of the Bush administration.

Brennan, Parenteau and most wildlife advocates aren't ready to give up on most species. But they no longer are looking to return ecosystems to a former pristine state. Climate change will eliminate many ecosystems around the world and create new ones that no longer can sustain the creatures and plants there now, Brennan said.

Many ecosystems that will exist in 2100 exist nowhere on Earth today, she said.

"Our grandchildren are going to grow up in a world that's unrecognizable today," said Dale Goble, a University of Idaho law professor and co-author of the book, "The Endangered Species Act at Thirty."

The idea that we can address the threats that species face and bring them back to recovery is the core concept that underlies the Endangered Species Act, Goble said. But "recovery" - as the law requires - is not likely to be an option.

At least 80 percent of endangered species and even many game species that survive will need special, individual management into perpetuity, Goble said.

Species like pikas, a small mountain mammal, and even mountain goats that live in high mountains will lose their habitat and are likely to go extinct.

The warmer weather already may be affecting diseases, which could be moving north into new habitat now warm enough to let them thrive. A parasitic brain worm is killing moose in Minnesota. West Nile virus, carried by mosquitoes, has moved west and north to threaten sage grouse and kill people.

"We have to get a whole lot lighter on our feet," Goble said. "We have to be able to act more quickly. Taking risks means you have to try something and if it doesn't work you have to try something else."

Parenteau has been training environmental lawyers for years to slow things down so that more deliberative decisions are made about development. But now he advocates changes in the National Environmental Policy Act that would allow the nation to move faster on alternative energy development like wind, solar and other non-carbon sources.

He points to held-up wind projects and a recent moratorium on solar development in Western desert areas.

Meanwhile, competing environmental needs are making tough decisions even harder.

In the latest lawsuit against the dams on the Snake and Columbia rivers, salmon advocates pointed out the lack of a definitive discussion on the effects of climate change on salmon.

Tim Personius, deputy regional director of the Bureau of Reclamation, which manages some of those dams, wonders if the salmon advocates are looking at the big picture.

The salmon groups say the only way to recover Snake River salmon is to breach four dams on the river in Washington - but the electrical generation lost would have to be replaced with sources more damaging to the climate.

"That effectively would increase carbon emissions an average of 4 million tons per year," Personius said.

Parenteau believes the tradeoff of removing the relatively lowpower dams to restore salmon is worth the carbon impacts. But he acknowledged that considerations like the larger impacts on thousands of species - including the salmon - from climate change should be taken into account in Endangered Species Act decisions.

Salmon advocates may have to consider replacing the power from the dams with nuclear power, said Virgil Moore, Idaho Department of Fish and Game deputy director.

"I suspect many of us aren't putting that on the table," Moore said. "We know the risk and it's scary, but the risks of climate change are really scary."

Parenteau has opposed nuclear power in the past and he's still not ready to support it as part of the solution for climate change.

"But for people like me, nuclear power is on the table," he said.

That kind of change may seem like a major shift, but the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's Burgett said people will have to change their perceptions about many things - even such core ideas as the concept of sustainability.

"If you are talking about sustaining the world we have now," he said, "it's too late."

Related Pages:
We Shouldn't Give Up on ESA or Any Species in Jeopardy by Dr. Jean Brennan, Bellingham Herald, 7/9/8

Rocky Barker
Wildlife Experts are Resigned to Extinction of Some Species
Bellingham Herald, June 30, 2008

See what you can learn

learn more on topics covered in the film
see the video
read the script
learn the songs
discussion forum
salmon animation