Fish Health & Stress
Related to Transportation
Idaho Fish & Game Report to the Director 5/1/98
Does fish health suffer from the stress related to transportation?
Conclusion: Collection and barging through the upper Snake and Columbia river corridor represents the largest fish health danger to upper snake River stocks of anadromous fish by exposing chinook to overwhelming stress and to horizontal transmission of etiologic agents, particularly Renibacterium salmoninarum (RS), Bacterial Kidney Disease (BKD).
Several aspects of fish health and stress issues are related to transportation. These are dealt within the context of the differences and similarities of spring/summer chinook stocks which PATH identified as being Snake River drainage, Upper Columbia River drainage, and Lower Columbia River drainages as follows:
Data on fish health status of hatchery and wild, juvenile and adult spring/summer chinook was sought from ODFW, WDFW, and USFWS. The fish health database of the Eagle Fish Health Lab was also queried for the same information. The primary salmonid disease issue related to transportation, identified by NMFS and the Independent Scientific Review Group, has been BKD caused by RS. Consequently, our primary focus was to collect data on juvenile and adult chinook related to RS and BKD. Excellent cooperation was obtained from all the agencies. Most of the agencies provided detection data from enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) analyses conducted since 1991 when the application of ELISA became standard in the Columbia River Basin.
There are several premises which relate to this issue: BKD has been implicated to be the cause of delayed mortality following release of transported chinook; BKD occurs in Snake River Basin hatchery chinook at a greater rate and level (prevalence and intensity of infection) than in chinook stocks from the two other locations identified by PATH; BKD is a problem of hatchery chinook and not of wild chinook; that IDFG has not taken steps to control BKD in its hatchery programs; and that diseases other than BKD need to be addressed.
It is very important to emphasize the difference between detection of the pathogen (RS) which causes BKD and the clinical disease itself. This was the subject of a symposium sponsored by the Pacific Northwest Fish Health Protection Committee (PNFHPC, 1997). This point is often lost in discussions of this nature, but is the cornerstone of fish health. There is ample data indicating that detection of the disease agent does not always constitute disease. All managing agencies differentiate between detection and disease. Clinical BKD (the disease state) is associated with ELISA values greater than an optical density (OD) value of 1.0 and correlates well with observing RS from kidney smears by optical methods as well as the progression to the death of the host (Pascho et al. 1993). Environmental factors are key to whether the disease agent becomes problematic. These environmental factors include both those external and internal to the fish host. Most factors are stressors and some will be identified in the section on Stress to follow.
Premises: BKD CAUSES DELAYED MORTALITY
Bacterial kidney disease is a chronic, debilitating disease, meaning it causes mortality within a population over a long period of time following a protracted incubation period, which is inversely related to water temperature (Sanders et al. 1978). Post-challenge incubation periods usually exceed 100 days at water temperatures experienced during transportation and in the Columbia River estuary (Murray et al. 1992). Infections with RS have been shown to inhibit smoltification and delay salt water entry. Consequently, the mortality rate is exacerbated in salt water compared with freshwater (Banner et al. 1983). Therefore, BKD has been implicated to be a cause of delayed mortality. Infection rates in hatchery and wild chinook smolts captured at Jones Beach in the Columbia River estuary have been about 25% (Sanders et al. 1992).
Exceptions to this "rule" have been seen with Idaho and Oregon wild chinook taken as parr and reared in either fresh or salt water in the captive propagation programs. Mortality attributed to BKD has been more severe in freshwater than in salt water. Chinook demonstrated to be infected with RS were able to resolve the infection when reared under optimal conditions in salt water (Thorarinsson et al. 1994; Elliott et al. 1995). This provides a link between culture conditions, stress, and mortality to BKD (Congleton et al. 1984). These exceptions indicated that only those fish which had relatively high ELISA values subsequently succumbed to the infection and that those with low values were able to cope with and resolve the infection.
CONCLUSION: BKD can be the cause of delayed mortality which may be amplified after entry into salt water particularly when initial infection rates are high and when environmental conditions which are not optimal.
Premise: BKD IS A HATCHERY DISEASE
Research by Pascho and Elliott (1991) on the effect of BKD and the transportation process examined ELISA values of wild and hatchery chinook captured at Lower Granite Dam. They concluded that both wild and hatchery chinook from the Snake River had detectable levels of RS by ELISA. Some years, the prevalence of RS in wild chinook exceeded that of hatchery fish. However, ELISA optical density values were generally low in wild fish. ELISA values of hatchery and wild chinook collected from the three sections of the Columbia River Basin considered by the PATH process will follow. A topic for which there is not much data is the correlation of ELISA value at collection with the subsequent mortality. This mortality data must be partitioned between those fish which were initially infected from those subsequently infected by cohabitation during the holding period.
Observations from IDFG's captive propagation programs which originate from collections of wild parr and smolt sockeye and chinook from three river systems illustrate that BKD was presently in a small percentage of the wild fish. Mortality attributed to BKD which occurred within the first five months following collection was low indicating that these wild fish may have had RS in the carrier state but that progression to the disease state was rare. For Redfish Lake sockeye and Salmon River chinook, it appears that about 0.2% of over 1,000 sockeye smolts and 0.7% of the chinook parr carried RS. These rates of infection are similar to those found as "highs" within the Snake and Columbia River Basin areas shown in Table 1.
CONCLUSION: Both wild and hatchery chinook of the Snake River have detectable, but low intensity levels of RS.
Premise: INFECTION RATES ARE MUCH HIGHER IN SNAKE RIVER CHINOOK COMPARED TO RATES OBSERVED IN CHINOOK FROM THE UPPER COLUMBIA AND LOWER COLUMBIA RIVER AREAS
Survey data for juvenile and adult chinook from the areas of the Columbia River Basin areas identified by PATH are summarized in Table 1. Most of these data are from hatchery populations except for the ID/NE OR area. Some of these data originate from transportation studies on wild and hatchery chinook of the Snake River by Pascho and Elliott (1991). They demonstrated that RS could be detected in water of the post-collection holding raceways and barge hold and that brook trout contracted BKD when exposed to these environments. RS was not in sufficient quantity to be detected in waters of the Snake River outside of the barge hold. They also determined that chinook with ELISA values exceeding 2.0 (very high level) were those shown to shed RS into the water.
Chinook of all three areas have been demonstrated to harbor antigens of RS regardless of which area of the Snake River and Columbia River they originated from. Both the prevalence and intensity of infection of those originating from the Snake River Basin were frequently lower than those of either the Upper and Lower Columbia River Basin area. Detections of smolts with clinical BKD by ELISA are rare. These data illustrate the need to avoid the crowded conditions, such as barging, where horizontal transmission from the few "highs" could occur. The actual transmission of BKD from hatchery to wild chinook (or vice versa) through smolt collection and subsequent barging has not been demonstrated (Steward and Bjornn 1990).
CONCLUSION: BKD is no more prevalent in Snake River systems than elsewhere and infectious diseases would not constrain recovery of these stocks if migration conditions in the mainstem are corrected.
Premise: IDFG HAS NOT TAKEN MEASURES TO CONTROL BKD WITHIN ITS HATCHERIES
The evolution of fish culture methods for successful control of BKD in chinook has emphasized injection of returning adults with Erythromycin (Klontz. 1982), feeding the same antibiotic to juveniles (Moffitt and Schreck. 1988), and segregation rearing (with or without culling of progeny from females demonstrated to be clinically infected with BKD (Pascho et al. 1991) IDFG has been proactive in the application of these practices over the last two decades. Application of the most effective combination of these practices has resulted in marked reduction in the occurrence of clinical BKD at IDFG facilities (Figure 1; Munson 1998). These improvements have been observed by reduced detection of clinically infected chinook at collection facilities of the dams on the lower Snake River (Maule et al. 1996; VanderKooi and Maule. In press).
CONCLUSION: Dramatic reduction in clinical BKD has occurred at IDFG facilities over the last decade.
Premise: DISEASES OTHER THAN BKD NEED TO BE ADDRESSED
Myxobolus cerebralis, the myxozoan parasite which can cause whirling disease was demonstrated to infect chinook at Sawtooth and Pahsimeroi Hatcheries in 1987. Facility management actions were implemented to limit exposure of small fish to the infective river water at both sites. This action has been demonstrated to be effective in Europe and has limited infections to the asymptomatic carrier state. Approximately 4.6% of wild chinook parr collected for the chinook captive propagation program have been shown to be infected with M. Cerebralis, but whirling disease has not caused any mortality after 2.5 years of rearing. Infections of returning adults have also been at the carrier level. It is doubtful that this parasite exerts a limiting effect on chinook populations in the Salmon River.
Erythrocytic Inclusion Body Syndrome (EIBS) occurs at a higher rate in hatchery chinook (70%) than those produced naturally (50%) in the Snake River Basin (PNFHPC 1997). This viral condition, deemed "fuzzy-tail." Has been shown to be debilitating to chinook at Rapid River Hatchery. It was especially prevalent in the late 1980's but has diminished dramatically once BKD was controlled with Erythromycin therapy (Munson 1998).
Table 1Comparison of adult and juvenile spring/summer chinook BKD ELISA categories for Snake River, Upper Columbia River, and Lower Columbia River for the years 1991-1997.
|Idaho / Northeast Oregon|
|Upper / Mid Columbia River|
|Lower Columbia River|
BL = Below Low, ELISA OD < 0.1
L = Low, ELISA OD 0.1 TO 0.2
M = Moderate, ELISA OD 0.2 to 0.45
H = High, ELISA OD > 0.45
A variety of biological, physical, and chemical factors are capable of challenging the physiological systems of fish, forcing the fish to adapt to survive. Selye (1950) described stress and the general adaptation syndrome (GAS) which states that if an animal is stressed long enough, the physiologic systems will adapt to accommodate the stress to maintain or reestablish a normal metabolism. Once the accommodating systems are exhausted, the animal will die. It is well established that acute and chronic stress that approaches physiological tolerance limits of fish will impair reproductive success, growth, resistance to infectious disease, and survival (Wedemeyer et al. 1990). The cumulative effects of stress may reduce recruitment to successive life stage and eventually cause populations to decline (Vaughn et al. 1984; Adams et al. 1985).
Several authors have described the stressors and the cascade of events that follow stress-related events during collection, barging and release of anadromous fish (Congleton 1984; Bjornn 1984, 1986 and 1987; Wedemeyer 1985; Pascho and Elliott 1993; Schreck 1998). Taken individually, these stressors may not be directly lethal, but the cumulative effect does change a group of individual stressors into a deadly gauntlet which poses the overwhelming threat at any life stage to wild and hatchery anadromous fish.
Location/actions which appear to be most stressful in the collection and transportation process vary in fish response. The separation step and loading the barges were found to be high point sources of stress for chinook. Lesser reactions were noticed during holding the fish in raceways (exposed to direct sunlight) and unloading the barges during these studies. Trucking fish exacted more stress from chinook than barging, because recovery from stress was achieved during barging. Transporting chinook with steelhead was more stressful to chinook than if chinook were transported without steelhead. Barge loads at near maximum densities created higher levels of stress than loads well below maximum density. Decreased adult return rates have been demonstrated from chinook with elevated stress levels during transportation. Stress and delayed mortality are related topics especially when dealing with BKD (Schreck, 1998; Pascho & Elliott, 1993). Cohabitation of high titer RS individual fish with low titer fish, exacerbates horizontal transmission, with the prolonged time of infection to death (up to 104 days). Thus, most deaths would occur in the salt water stage. Chinook which are disoriented, diseased, and/or with diminished smoltification are predisposed to predation after release from the barges and passage through dams (Schreck, 1998).
Smoltification and migration of chinook are normal, but chronically stressful events (Steward and Bjornn 1990). The success of regional anadromous fish restoration efforts rests on immediate improvements in the quality of the mainstem corridor (Bisbal 1998). Linkage of Idaho spawning habitats (and hatcheries) to the ocean is crucial to Idaho anadromous stocks. Mainstem alterations have slowed migration, supersaturated the water with nitrogen, and provide a beneficial habitat for predators (squawfish). Collection and barging have been implemented to circumvent these adverse migration conditions but are themselves inherently stressful. These additional acute and chronic stressors diminish and drain the anadromous populations' ability to survive. The cumulative effects of all factors natural and manmade, need to be considered The unnecessary stressors should be eliminated from this process. IDFG feels that the choice of a normative river is the best way to achieve this result.
CONCLUSION: Collection and barging through the Snake River and Columbia River corridor represents the largest fish health danger to upper Snake River stocks of anadromous fish by exposing chinook to overwhelming stress and to horizontal transmission of etiologic agents, particularly Renibaterium
Appendix 3.3 IDAHO's ANADROMOUS FISH STOCKS:
Their Status and Recovery Options
Report to the Director Idaho Fish & Game 5/1/98
Issue Paper: Fish Health and Stress Related to Transportation
learn more on topics covered in the film
see the video
read the script
learn the songs