the film
Commentaries and editorials

Salmon Groups Ask Redden
to Push Settlement Talks

by Rocky Barker
Idaho Statesman, November 17, 2011

Snake River Chinook Salmon in-river Survival 1964-2010. When Idaho Sen. Mike Crapo turned down the call by Nez Perce Chairman Brooklyn Baptiste for setting a "solution table" for Columbia-Snake salmon-dam talks it was clear there was nothing going to happen soon unless U.S. District Judge James Redden made it happen.

So the tribe and other salmon advocates recently requested a settlement judge be appointed by the Court to help improve the process of finding solutions to save endangered Columbia and Snake River salmon and steelhead. The federal agencies responded to the request this week, calling the process "improper and should be denied." he agencies argue the sovereign collaborative process with the tribes and the states that they had before is what Redden wants them to continue.

"We will be using the same collaboration approach we used with the existing biological opinion," said Will Stelle, regional director of NOAA Fisheries.

In short, they replied, "Now is the time to stay the course."

But that process could not bring the Nez Perce and Oregon on board with them and leaves the environmental and sportsmen groups who sued on the sidelines.

So with a deadline of 2013 to write a new plan and a critical election in 2012, the Obama administration is hoping they can delay anything big. Administration officials hope that by continuing to do what they're doing now, which make no mistake is not cheap, they can avoid the tough choices until later.

Since the salmon advocates really don't have any leverage outside of Redden they are resting their hopes on him and good rhetoric.

"You'd have to believe in the tooth fairy to believe that the regional federal agencies are either truly consulting with all relevant parties in a meaningful way, or likely to develop a scientifically and legally responsible plan after failing miserably four times previously," said Bill Arthur, National Field Director of the Sierra Club.

Rocky Barker
Salmon Groups Ask Redden to Push Settlement Talks
Idaho Statesman, November 17, 2011

See what you can learn

learn more on topics covered in the film
see the video
read the script
learn the songs
discussion forum
salmon animation