the film
Commentaries and editorials

Salmon: No Dam Difference?

by Editorial Board
The Oregonian, October 29, 2008

The study found comparable survival for young salmon on the Columbia and the Fraser River, which has no dams. It is an article of faith among Northwest conservation and sport-fishing groups that dam removal is the only real answer to the ailing salmon runs in the Columbia and Snake rivers. How, then, do they explain the results of a study showing that salmon survival on the Columbia and Canada's famous Fraser River, which has no dams, were roughly the same?

Yes, there are many differences between the Columbia and the Fraser, which has its own problems with pollution and development, as The Oregonian's Michael Milstein reported. And there's nothing about the Fraser River's survival rate -- only about 25 percent to 50 percent of its young salmon make it down the river to its mouth -- that should be the ultimate goal of those trying to restore the Columbia runs.

But the study, which carries the overly provocative title "Dams Make No Damn Difference to Salmon Survival," should at least force all the interest groups in the Northwest to pause and consider whether they have too quickly and easily dismissed the effects of hundreds of millions of dollars of fish passage improvements installed at Columbia and Snake river dams.

It's considered bad form in the Northwest salmon debate to say anything positive about the Bonneville Power Administration and the Army Corps of Engineers, but it does appear that the fish-friendly improvements at their dams have helped counter the harm of the power-generation structures. It also appears that efforts to control squawfish and other predators in the Columbia system, which isn't done on the Fraser, might be helping the salmon.

Dams do kill young salmon trying to survive their journey downstream. We'll never believe anyone's claim that they "make no damn difference" to salmon. But this study, and other lesser publicized findings, have shown a marked increase in downstream smolt survival on the Columbia.

Again, we're in no way suggesting that all's well with Columbia and Snake River salmon. Young salmon mortality is still unacceptably high. The study, which used young salmon implanted with acoustic tracking devices, showed that about half of spring chinook that start from an Idaho hatchery on the Snake River made it all the way to Bonneville Dam. Many more of those fish disappeared in the last stretch of the Columbia near its mouth, eaten by seabirds.

Adult returns are anemic, too. It's surely possible, as some researchers argue, that young smolts may survive the long run through the dam system so weakened and stressed that they will die later.

The latest study won't be the last word on the subject of Columbia salmon. But it provides an interesting comparison to a river without dams, and provides support for the huge and continuing investments in dam modifications and predator control efforts meant to protect migrating salmon on the Columbia. They are making a difference for fish.

Related Pages:
Biodiversity: Unraveling the Mysteries of Salmon Migration by Stephen Leahy, Science Daily, 10/31/8
Do Dams Make A Difference? IPS News, 10/30/8
Salmon Study Yields Surprise Result by Jeff Barnard, Capital Press, 10/30/8
Readers Discuss POST article by Reader Discussion, The Oregonian, 10/29/8
Salmon: No Dam Difference? by Editorial Board, The Oregonian, 10/29/8
Track the Salmon in California by Editorial Board, Contra Costa Times, 10/29/8
New Study Finds Fish Do as Well on Dammed Rivers by Editorial Board, Walla Walla Union-Bulletin, 10/29/8
Dams Appear to Have No Impact on Salmon by Michael Reilly, Discovery News, 10/29/8
Salmon Smolt Survival Similar in Columbia and Fraser by Mark Floyd, Eureka Alert, 10/27/8
Salmon Study Under Fire for Minimizing Effect of Dams by Warren Cornwall, Seattle Times, 10/27/8
Research Hints Dam Improvements Helping Salmon by Michael Milstein, The Oregonian, 10/27/8
Dams Not Main Cause of Salmon Collapse, Study Says by James Owen, National Geographic News, 10/27/8
Study Shows More Salmon Survive West's Dammed Rivers Canadian Press, 10/27/8
Radio Tags Shed Light on Salmon Migration Routes by Mark Hume, Globe and Mail, 10/27/8

Editorial Board
Salmon: No Dam Difference?
The Oregonian, October 29, 2008

See what you can learn

learn more on topics covered in the film
see the video
read the script
learn the songs
discussion forum
salmon animation