Appeals Court Affirms Order for More Spill
by Courtney Flatt
The federal government will have to spill more water over Columbia and Snake river dams starting Tuesday in an effort to help young salmon migrating to the ocean. This will make up the biggest planned water spill over dams for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.
The requirement comes after the Ninth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals on Monday affirmed an order for federal dam managers on the Columbia and Snake rivers to comply with a judge's ruling from last year. The National Marine Fisheries Service had appealed U.S. District Judge Michael Simon's ruling to increase spill over dams.
"After more than 20 years of federal failure, salmon are in desperate need of help now," said Todd True, Earthjustice attorney representing conservation, fishing, and clean energy advocates in the case, in a statement.
"The measures the court upheld will give salmon a fighting chance while the federal government catches up to the scale and urgency of what the law requires to protect these fish from extinction."
Spilling water in the springtime over the tops of dams -- rather than sending it through turbine blades -- is seen by conservation groups as an essential way to protect threatened and endangered salmon and steelhead. The increased spill will take place from April to mid-June.
Advocates say it allows juvenile salmon to quickly pass over dams, rather than sending them through the structures, which can cause traumatic damage to the fish as they head to sea.
"It's tragic that the federal agencies are still ignoring their own science in fighting spill at every step of the way," said Glen Spain, with the Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen's Associations, in a news release.
Conservation groups say this is the fourth time since 2005 that the U.S. District Court has ordered increased spill over the dams.
"This is a short-term measure, but it's a critical one, given that salmon populations -- especially in the last few years -- are headed in the wrong direction. They need more help right now, not less," said Joseph Bogaard, executive director of Save Our Wild Salmon.
The move has been controversial. First, opponents say, less water through dams means less power generated. Second, they say, too much spill can lead to too much dissolved oxygen in the water, which also causes problems for fish.
Terry Flores, the executive director of Northwest RiverPartners, a group that opposes the increased spill, said she supports fish recovery plans that are "wise, not wasteful."
"It could very well harm the fish that we are trying to protect," Flores said. "At best this more forced spill … will at best shave off a few hours of travel time for young fish heading downstream."
The Bonneville Power Administration estimates the increased spill could cost up to $40 million per year, which will be passed on to ratepayers under a "spill surcharge."
Dam managers say spilling too much water incorrectly over the dams can create eddies, where young fish are vulnerable to predators, and it can eventually damage the dams. Officials have been testing new spill plans on miniature dams to make sure they find the right solution.
Republican lawmakers and other dam supporters including farmers and power trade groups criticized the court decision. They said the increase to ratepayers and the energy lost is too much for something they say won't help fish.
"It's like flushing money down the river," said U.S. Rep. Dan Newhouse, R-Washington at a news conference Monday.
The Bonneville Power Administration said it's "analyzing the full financial impacts of this court decision."
Newhouse said the groups will work to prevent further spill increases on the river system.
The increased spill will start Tuesday on the Snake River and April 10 on the Columbia River.
learn more on topics covered in the film
see the video
read the script
learn the songs