the film
Commentaries and editorials

Farmers Don't Need Dams

by Janice Inghram
Lewiston Tribune, November 28, 2017

A Tidewater grain barge became stuck Dec. 19 on the Snake River near the Port of Clarkston in Clarkston, Wash. Two tugboats worked to free the full barge for more than four hours, according to port manager Wanda Keefer. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers is awaiting further information from Tidewater before taking action. I often read barging wheat on the lower Snake River is critically important to maintaining wheat production in eastern Washington and north central Idaho. Without Snake River barging, so I'm told, wheat farmers couldn't survive.

I'm puzzled. Farmers in the Inland Northwest grew wheat for 100 years before the lower Snake River dams were completed. Many wheat farmers on the Palouse ship by rail while others truck their wheat to barges on the Columbia. Wheat growers in Montana don't barge any wheat, but they remain in business.

With the loss of container shipping on the lower Snake, garbanzos and lentils and peas (pulse) are now transported by truck and rail. I haven't read any newspaper articles about pulse processors closing shop. I have read that area farmers are expanding their production of pulse crops.

If one of the dams or locks on the lower Snake suffered irreparable damage or the cost of repair was well beyond any possible economic justification, do you think the wheat farmers who still use the barge system would stop growing wheat?

Almost 90 percent of all freight shipped on the lower Snake River is grain. What if the farmers who still ship grain by barge had to pay even a third of the $10 million annual direct taxpayer cost of lock operations, and/or the $10 million spent on the last dredging project to keep the navigation channel open to the Port of Lewiston? How long do you think barging would last on the lower Snake?

Related Pages:
Huge Price to Pay by Linwood Laughy, Lewiston Tribune, 12/10/17
Valley Needs Navigation by Cole Riggers, Lewiston Tribune, 12/3/17

Janice Inghram, Grangeville
Farmers Don't Need Dams
Lewiston Tribune, November 28, 2017

See what you can learn

learn more on topics covered in the film
see the video
read the script
learn the songs
discussion forum
salmon animation