the film
Economic and dam related articles

Homeowners Dismiss Clouds,
Reap Benefits of Solar Panels

by Craig Sailor
The News Tribune, May 28, 2014

Overcast skies don't stop photovoltaic cells from pumping out the watts

(Drew Perine photo) South Sound Solar employees from right Aaron Bonfield, Daniel Kuni and Brian Jones install one of 10 Itek solar panels on the roof of an Olympia home. At some point just about every homeowner gives a thought to solar energy. Who wouldn't like to power their house with the sun, watch their electric meter run backwards and never pay for a kilowatt again?

And then the clouds set in. This is the Northwest, after all, not sunny Arizona.

But the sun finally is rising for good on solar power. Costs have come down, efficiency has gone up and financial incentives are increasing the return on investment.


In California, Hawaii or Arizona solar panels can be seen on many rooftops, but in the Northwest you're more likely to see Sasquatch than a solar electric array. Dispelling the notion that there's not enough sun to make a solar power system worthwhile is job number one for solar advocates.

Solar power will be one of the many topics covered at this weekend's Mother Earth News Fair at the Washington State Fair Events Center in Puyallup. The two-day event focuses on living green. (Check the box for details.)

"It absolutely does work here," Puget Sound Energy's Jake Wade said of solar power. There's no substitution for direct sunlight, he said. But summer's long days and lower energy needs (compared with power sucking Phoenix and Las Vegas) enable solar-equipped customers to produce more power than they need.

High heat makes photovoltaic solar panels less efficient. So, the Northwest's cool days help solar cells produce more energy.

And while overcast skies are not as productive as direct sun they make orientation and pitch of solar panels far less important. (The light is multidirectional.)

"I'm cranking out the watts right now," Dave Watterson of Tenino said on a sunny day last week. In 2011 Watterson installed a 6.48 kilowatt system. Pleased with the results he added another 2.88 kilowatts in 2013. His average $250 a month electric bill is now $70. He'd like to get it to zero.

"I'd have to add a few more kilowatts and I didn't have the space on my roof to do it," he said.

PSE has 2,021 solar producing customers. Solar energy now accounts for 1.13 percent of total U.S. capacity, according to figures just released by the U.S. Department of Energy. Since 2010 solar capacity increased by 418 percent across the nation.


While Northwest summers might be a solar paradise what happens during winter's short, dark days when the furnace runs day and night? That, say solar proponents, is when the beauty of net energy metering comes in to play.

NEM allows utility customers who generate their own renewable energy (including wind and hydro) to earn credits for surplus power they deliver to the grid. The Department of Energy cites NEM as one of the main drivers of the increased popularity of solar energy.

The system is simple. During the summer the energy a solar customer produces is sent back to the utility company. Meter discs actually spin backward. In the winter, when more energy is needed than produced, it's subtracted from the customer's account.

"It's like using the utility as an infinitely efficient battery," said Wade, who is PSE's net metering program manager.

Some customers, if they have a big enough system and/or are energy conservative, wind up paying nothing for their electricity. However, they still pay a small monthly bill to the utility for service.

On a sunny day last week the disc in Dohn and Chris Swedberg's meter was spinning furiously in reverse. The 49 panels on the west facing roof of their house overlooking the Tacoma Narrows and the south facing roof of their garage were creating more than enough energy to fully power their home -- with the air conditioner running.

Dohn, an architect, designed the home to take advantage of passive solar energy long before he installed the PV panels. It sits snug against the site's slope and has most of its windows on the south and west sides.


"The greenest watt is the watt you never use," Wade said. Combining green power generation with conservation is the most efficient energy model.

"True net zero requires a change in lifestyle," said Kirk Haffner. The 50-year-old Olympia-based solar installer has had a life-long interest in solar but didn't start his company until 2008. He now has 12 employees.

Haffner is a solar evangelist. His Olympia office is fully solar powered (his most recent utility bill was $10.16 and only covered administrative costs), his home uses solar heated water and he turned a Ford Escort into a solar powered car (it runs on solar charged batteries.)

Despite Haffner's gung-ho attitude he dissuades customers who simply want a lower energy bill. Instead, he encourages them to get an energy audit first. Those that do install solar almost always change the way they consume energy as well, he said.

"This industry causes people to look at how they produce and consume energy," he said. That includes low energy lighting, weatherization and energy efficient appliances.

When Watterson went solar he also installed LED lights, a ductless heat pump and an energy efficient hot water system. He also bought an electric car.

"It's a challenge to see how much you can save," Watterson said.

Watterson and Haffner are not the only solar enthusiasts with electric cars. In fact, electric vehicles are proving to be a common incentive for switching to solar power, said Robert Grothe of North West Solar Group, a Tacoma based nonprofit solar advocacy organization.

"It doesn't take that much solar to cover your electric vehicle," Wade said. PSE estimates that it would take a 3 kilowatt array to power a typically driven electric vehicle averaged over a year.

David Lee, a resident of Tacoma's North End, has 28 PV panels that produce 6.3 kilowatts of energy. The 4-feet-by-4-feet panels are made by Silicon Energy of Marysville. He has no regrets going solar and plans on increasing the size of his system soon.

"It's the right thing to do. It's the sustainable thing to do. It's the economical thing to do," Lee said.


Each 1,000 watts of PV solar panel produces about 1,000 kilowatt hours of electricity per year. The typical home in Western Washington uses 900 to 1,000 kilowatt hours per month, Wade said. To be completely net zero that home would need an array that produced 10 to 12 kilowatts. The median size of a solar system for a PSE customer is 4 to 5 kilowatts, he said.

The biggest stumbling block for most solar power seekers is cost. A full system could set a homeowner back $30,000. But costs have dropped dramatically in recent years.

In 2008, when Haffner first started his business, a system cost $8-10 per watt to install. Now, it's $3-5 per watt installed. Most of his clients spend $20,000 to $30,000.

When Watterson first looked at solar in 2003 he said it was only for the rich. But by 2011, prices had dropped and he was able to fund 100 percent of his system with a credit union loan designed specifically for solar systems.

And while prices could continue to drop, Haffner said, they've stabilized.

The solar panel industry is highly competitive. Federal prosecutors last week indicted five Chinese military officials for stealing industrial secrets from Hillsboro, Oregon, based solar panel manufacturer SolarWorld.

Other factors driving cost include choice of product and difficulty of installation.


The heart of any solar system is its PV cells. The delicate silicon-based wafers are interconnected and assembled in to sturdy panels, usually about 40 inches by 65 inches. Depending on manufacturer and model the panels can produce from 200 to 300 watts. After quality of the panels, buyers should be concerned with efficiency, price, warranty and aesthetics, Haffner said.

Panel maker SunPower sets the market record at 21.5 percent efficiency. That means that 21.5 percent of light hitting the cells is output as energy in ideal, laboratory conditions. That's almost a doubling since the Carter administration when the president famously installed panels on the White House roof. They were later removed by President Ronald Reagan.

Scientists have recently announced the development of cells that absorb different wavelengths of sunlight and achieve efficiency in excess of 40 percent. But those cells are years from production and affordability. The development does mean that fewer cells will be needed to achieve the same power output of today's systems.

Another breakthrough came in inverter efficiency. The inverter is what converts DC power (which the panels produce) to AC power (for home use.) Once at 80 percent efficiency they now run up to 97 percent.

Up until the early 2000s batteries were required but are now no longer needed. Batteries still can be added to a system but add cost and are not needed with NEM. Batteries are a must for off grid systems.


The optimum location for solar panels is a south facing, pitched roof, Haffner said. That takes advantage of the most light. A west facing roof is the next best choice but is 15 percent less productive.

A roof pitch of 30 to 35 degrees is optimum. (That equates to a roof rising 7 to 8 vertical inches over 12 linear inches.)

Even if a property owner has plenty of land a roof provides a ready-made, engineered structure and needs the least amount of wiring. At least 75 percent of Haffner's customers place their panels on roofs. If a roof isn't at the right pitch or orientation the panels can be racked to the correct placement. However, that will add to the cost.

Other locations include pole and ground mounted panels but both of those also add to installation costs. Some advanced pole systems allow the panels to track the sun through the day.

Some of Haffner's clients get creative. He's installed panels on car ports, pergolas and even on a chicken coop. David Lee attached an awning to his house made of solar panels. He plans on adding another soon.

Roof mounted systems come with flashing that prevents leaks. Haffner uses only systems that are guaranteed and warranted not to leak.


But wait, there's more. If free power isn't a strong enough attraction the financial incentives don't end there.

Aside from NEM, Washington utility companies administer an incentive program that buys the energy produced by individuals and companies (up to $5,000 per participant per year) regardless of whether it goes to the grid or is used by the customer. If the solar equipment used is made in Washington, then the kilowatt hours produced is paid at 54 cents. If out-of-state equipment is used, then it drops to 15 cents.

Watterson used Bellingham-made Itek panels for his project and is able to receive the 54 cents. The incentive program runs through 2020. In 2013 PSE paid just under $1.9 million to its solar customers.

David Lee displays the checks he has received from the city of Tacoma next to his converter. His latest was for $2,940. Meanwhile, over at the Narrows the Swedbergs have maxed out the $5,000 annual payment. They estimate they produce $5,200 worth of energy in a year.

Additionally, a solar power customer can take 30 percent of the system cost off their federal income tax bill. That means a $30,000 system would end up costing $21,000 after taxes. Furthermore, all parts and installation costs are sales-tax free in Washington.

When it comes time to sell your home a solar PV system will add to its value. The Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory found in 2013 that a home with a solar system added $24,000 to its sale price compared with homes without systems.


Solar energy might be a victim of its own success. Utility companies have recently begun to push back against NEM in the Sun Belt states.

Politicians in California and other sunny states are under pressure from utilities and their lobbyists to retool incentive programs. The companies say renewable energy customers need to share the costs of energy transmission and distribution. Environmentalists say the traditional utility business models are under threat.

Wade said PSE is looking closely at the situations in the Sun Belt states. He acknowledges that the battles will be fought there before they come, if ever, to the Northwest. But, he said, PSE will not stand in the way of renewable energy.

"If this is the direction our customers are going then this is the direction we're going."

Craig Sailor
Homeowners Dismiss Clouds, Reap Benefits of Solar Panels
The News Tribune, May 28, 2014

See what you can learn

learn more on topics covered in the film
see the video
read the script
learn the songs
discussion forum
salmon animation