the film
Commentaries and editorials

Farmers Right to be Skeptical
of Being Made Whole

by Editorial Board
Capital Press, January 2, 2020

According to the study, farmers don't believe they will be made whole.

Improvements will be made to the Ice Harbor Dam's navigation lock equipment during a 14-week-long navigation outage on the Snake and Columbia River system starting late this year. (Tri-City Herald file photo) The results of a study of stakeholder attitudes regarding the proposed breaching of Snake River dams were hardly surprising, but ag interests say the document may serve to educate proponents of the complexities the issue presents.

We can only hope so.

The study was recommended by a task force on reviving the orca population in Puget Sound. Scientists blame a declining orca population on a lack of chinook salmon for the killer whales to eat.

All Snake River salmon runs are federally threatened or endangered species. Washington Gov. Jay Inslee and the Legislature supported the $750,000 study to catalog different perspectives on breaching the dams as a way to increase fish runs.

The preliminary study represents the views of farmers, tribes, environmentalists, fishermen, shippers and government officials.

Breaching the dams would make it impossible to ship grain down the Snake. Loss of water impounded by the dams would impact irrigation on thousands of acres of farmland, and the loss of electricity generated by the dams would increase the cost of pumping groundwater.

Proponents of breaching the dams have suggested that subsidies to farmers could be built into the multi-billion dollar price tag.

"It is important to make agriculture ‘whole,' so farmers do not suffer significant economic losses if the dams are breached," the study reported.

But, according to the study, farmers don't believe they will be made whole.

Farmers are worried about being "at the mercy of railroads" that would take over shipping and "skeptical" about switching to crops that use less water, according to the study.

Washington Grain Commission CEO Glen Squires said he appreciated that the report's writers captured different views on breaching the dams.

"I think they genuinely listened and began to realize this whole thing is more complicated than meets the eye," he said. "It's not as easy as giving a farmer a nickel, dime, 20 cents a bushel -- case solved."

Indeed, it is complicated. The livelihoods of farmers, barge operators, deck hands, dock workers and the vendors who support them hang in the balance. The loudest proponents of breaching the dams seem to have the least personally at stake.

We don't know anyone who is against saving the whales or the salmon if the real human costs and impacts can be realistically addressed. Count us as skeptical that could ever be the case.

Editorial Board
Farmers Right to be Skeptical of Being Made Whole
Capital Press, January 2, 2020

See what you can learn

learn more on topics covered in the film
see the video
read the script
learn the songs
discussion forum
salmon animation